Not sure what to make of this. I agree in principle, but I do think he's a bit over the top.

Comments

Mr Williams has a web page that is very anti-religion. I think he was looking for a fight. His kids are going to miss out if her goes diatnce education with them. A prep child's story!
I don't see the educational value of showing a bad PG-rated film to 5 year-olds. That's a pretty weak defense. Maybe they could teach about lumberjacks by showing Texas Chainsaw Massacre.
I think stories like this are more about grandstanding than principle. It's the same with that Islamic school having an issue about the bloody national anthem FFS. I think people need to focus on the real issues and get on with it.
The guy seems more anti-religious then atheist. Although i do agree with him that the movie and book are not appropriate in a class setting because it doesnt matter whether religion is being taught or not, those books have a religious background and other materials are available to use. The kids not going to school where there is a chaplain though is another whole issue, what exactly does a chaplain do in school?

(personally i disagree that Evan Almighty promotes religion, if anything in my view it makes fun of religion)
RE: Principle
I'm going to go out on a limb and say that I do indeed think there should be religious instruction in schools. But the kind that involves teaching religion from an educational angle, exploring the major religions of the world, and including the agnostic and atheist platform as well. And only at a high school level. I don't think kids of a young age are able to think analytically about these things.

I think it would be better to incorporate some understanding about religion in general, so kids grow up better equipped to call bullshit on someone or some group when they try to manipulate/fear monger under the pretense of religion. Religion is just like politics and should be treated as such. Since both are used as intellectual and moral weapons in adult society, I think it's better to arm kids with knowledge.
If they're teaching fairy tales, such as Aesop's and Grimm's, in school, they might as well allow the Noah's Ark story, too. It's all in how it's presented.
I love how the school can't even keep their lies straight. First they say thet there were "no references to 'God' or the biblical story of Noah's Ark made in Kathleen's classroom", and then they say that the children were shown a video of Evan Almighty [1]. Lemme see here: God? Check. Noah's Ark? Check. Idiot school administrators? Check and check!

Dunno how it is in Queensland, but that could cost someone his job here.

John

[1] Ignoring the whole "who though it was a good idea to show a PG movie to 5 year olds without telling their parents" question...
I teach kindergarten in California. First of all, showing a movie like Evan Almighty is so wrong, I know it would never happen in my school. No one would do something so stupid.
Also, the religion thing (like politics) is always difficult. I avoid it like crazy, but kids will bring in their little books and, in order to encourage their interest and self esteem, I'll read out loud about the baby Jesus or some such thing. But I'm extremely careful to not "teach" it.
I'm also careful to not call it a fairy tale, or dumb story or anything I might be thinking.

Actually, the longer I teach the more I find myself avoiding every single holiday as much as I can. It turns my stomach to teach about the pilgrims, Columbus and various American Presidents.

This year maybe I'll put up a pole and teach them about Festivus.
i also agree in principle - the suing maybe going over the top though - it's not like they actually showed "Noah's Ark" in school - but, then again - showing this movie is a pretty sneaky way of getting religion into school
My kids school actually puts on a nativity play every Christmas (this is despite the fact that 30% of the kids are Muslim and there are also a handful of Jewish, Hindu and Buddhist kids). I have stopped whinging about it though as noone else seems too bothered by it .... and then there is the small matter of my 5yo son being chosen to play Joseph this year. :) lol
I agree with Gunderson Bee's comment too.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

Snowy

About Me

Snowy
Australia
"The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. To be your own man is hard business. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself.": Rudyard Kipling - (1865-1936)

My Groups

Neighborhood

Explore friends, family, friends & family, or entire neighborhood.

Archives