A QUEENSLAND father of five has taken action in the Anti-Discrimination Commission after his four-year-old daughter was asked to help make a replica of Noah's Ark at the local state school.
Ron Williams, who has five children under the age of 10, is opposed to religious instruction in state schools.
He said he was taking action because he did not believe students should be "exposed to superstitious mumbo-jumbo, presented as fact, in an educational setting".
Mr Williams complained that his daughter, Kathleen, now 5, was asked to make the "sizeable" replica of Noah's Ark during her prep class at Gabbinbar State School, "despite the fact that Queensland Education bans prep children from taking part in religious education programs in state schools".
Mr Williams said the Ark replica was later pinned to the classroom wall, and the teacher showed his daughter a DVD "with a Genesis theme and a book about Noah's Ark".
The school denies the claim, saying the children were shown a video of Evan Almighty -- a comedy about a man who builds a replica of Noah's Ark -- and a book about the Ark as part of a unit of study on animals and the noises they make.
Mr Williams has withdrawn his daughter from Gabbinbar State School.
Besides taking action in the Anti-Discrimination Commission, Mr Williams intends to sue Queensland Education for the cost of having his children educated by distance education or some other, secular alternative to the state school program.
His two sons still attend Gabbinbar. His two other children are not of school-age.
In taking action against Kathleen's teacher, Trina Savio, and the school's principal, Greg Brand, Mr Williams said he was standing up for a "significant, disgruntled underbelly of parents" who do not want Christian stories taught at state schools.
He said Australians lived in a society with a separation of church and state and he was therefore protecting Kathleen's fundamental human right: freedom from religion.
Mr Williams's complaint said Christian groups had been emboldened in their efforts to "spread the word" in state schools by a Howard government program, launched in October last year, to fund chaplains in state schools.
Under the $90million School Chaplaincy Program, schools can apply for up to $20,000 a year to employ a chaplain to mentor students.
An evangelical group called Scripture Union has placed 500 chaplains in Queensland state schools in the past year, including 40 per cent of primary schools and 80 per cent of high schools.
A spokesman for Scripture Union, Mark Badham, said chaplains had been largely welcomed by parents.
Mr Williams last year removed two of his children from Middle Ridge State School, also in Toowoomba, after it decided to employ a chaplain. He re-enrolled the children at Gabbinbar State School in part because it did not have a chaplain.
Mr Williams said he had made it clear to the school that his children should not be "exposed to supernatural stories".
In a statement to The Australian, Queensland Education said there were "no references to 'God' or the biblical story of Noah's Ark made in Kathleen's classroom".
"Through negotiated planning, students began studying animals and used the book Trouble in the Ark as reference material," the statement said.
Comments
(personally i disagree that Evan Almighty promotes religion, if anything in my view it makes fun of religion)
I'm going to go out on a limb and say that I do indeed think there should be religious instruction in schools. But the kind that involves teaching religion from an educational angle, exploring the major religions of the world, and including the agnostic and atheist platform as well. And only at a high school level. I don't think kids of a young age are able to think analytically about these things.
I think it would be better to incorporate some understanding about religion in general, so kids grow up better equipped to call bullshit on someone or some group when they try to manipulate/fear monger under the pretense of religion. Religion is just like politics and should be treated as such. Since both are used as intellectual and moral weapons in adult society, I think it's better to arm kids with knowledge.
Dunno how it is in Queensland, but that could cost someone his job here.
John
[1] Ignoring the whole "who though it was a good idea to show a PG movie to 5 year olds without telling their parents" question...
Also, the religion thing (like politics) is always difficult. I avoid it like crazy, but kids will bring in their little books and, in order to encourage their interest and self esteem, I'll read out loud about the baby Jesus or some such thing. But I'm extremely careful to not "teach" it.
I'm also careful to not call it a fairy tale, or dumb story or anything I might be thinking.
Actually, the longer I teach the more I find myself avoiding every single holiday as much as I can. It turns my stomach to teach about the pilgrims, Columbus and various American Presidents.
This year maybe I'll put up a pole and teach them about Festivus.